In the realm of English football, the question arises: how many levels of refereeing and re-refereeing are necessary before a correct decision can be reached? This dilemma was perfectly illustrated during a recent match between Manchester United and Leicester City when Bruno Fernandes received a red card for a challenge on James Maddison.
Referee Chris Kavanagh wasted no time in brandishing the red card, deeming Fernandes’ tackle to be serious foul play. However, the subsequent review by VAR Peter Bankes did not result in an overturn of the decision. Interestingly, the FA’s disciplinary commission later ruled in favor of Manchester United’s appeal, allowing Fernandes to participate in future games.
Bruno Fernandes’ red card was a marginal call (Michael Regan/Getty Images)
The controversy surrounding Fernandes’ red card reflects the subjective nature of refereeing decisions in football. While some may argue that the tackle warranted a red card, others believe it to be a marginal call. This disparity in opinions is what makes the VAR system and subsequent review processes so perplexing.
Despite the promise of VAR to provide objective accuracy, the reality is quite different. The recent events only serve to highlight the shortcomings of relying solely on technology to make critical decisions during matches. The emotional toll on fans, the uncertainty of goal celebrations, and the disconnect from the game’s essence all point towards a need for reevaluation.
GO DEEPER
VAR explained: What is it? Why is it controversial? How might the Premier League ditch it?
As fans, players, and officials grapple with the implications of VAR in English football, the debate continues. Is striving for complete accuracy in decisions worth sacrificing the essence of the game? Perhaps it’s time to reassess the role of technology in the sport and prioritize the fan experience above all else.
VAR has sucked the joy out of goal celebrations (Marc Atkins/Getty Images)
The current controversy surrounding VAR begs the question: is it time to reconsider its place in English football? Perhaps it’s time for a more human-centered approach to decision-making on the field, one that truly captures the spirit and emotion of the game.
Only time will tell if the English football authorities will heed the calls for change and prioritize the fans’ experience over technological advancements. Until then, the debate rages on, with each contentious decision serving as a reminder of the fine line between progress and tradition in the beautiful game.
(Top photo: Michael Regan/Getty Images)
