Each Sunday, three of The Athletic’s NFL writers react to the biggest news, plays, and performances from the day’s games.
The first Sunday of the NFL season brought thrilling action, surprises, and some standout performances. From a dominant Dallas display to a shaky start for the draft’s top pick, the day was filled with drama and excitement.
Despite changes in coaching staff and roster, some teams saw familiar results, while others faced unexpected challenges. It left fans wondering about the long-term implications of these early games.
Jerod Mayo gets his first win as @Patriots head coach 👏 pic.twitter.com/xXpEQ18ehQ
— NFL (@NFL) September 8, 2024
Now, let’s delve into the insights shared by The Athletic NFL writers Mike Jones, Ted Nguyen, and Dan Pompei on key storylines from the weekend.
Are the Dallas Cowboys a force to be reckoned with, or did the Cleveland Browns stumble?
Jones: The Cowboys showcased their potential in a solid opening performance, proving they are a team to watch this season. On the other hand, the Browns struggled, revealing areas they need to address, especially on offense. Deshaun Watson’s performance raised concerns, highlighting the challenges the Browns face in integrating new elements into their game plan.
Nguyen: The Cowboys’ defense stood out, putting pressure on Watson and setting a high bar for their opponents. The Browns’ injuries and offensive woes hindered their performance, posing questions about their ability to adapt and perform consistently.
Pompei: Dallas has the right pieces in place to contend, and their strong start is a testament to their potential. The Browns, despite their struggles, have room to improve and adjust, but the pressure is on to deliver better outcomes in the coming weeks.
How promising is the Los Angeles Chargers’ formula under Jim Harbaugh’s leadership?
Nguyen: The Chargers’ win showcased a methodical approach, with a focus on defense and efficient offense. Harbaugh’s influence was evident in their strategic play and the team’s ability to overcome challenges.
Pompei: Harbaugh’s coaching style has historically led to success, and the Chargers seem to be adapting well to their new system. With a strong defense and room for offensive growth, the Chargers have the potential to be competitive in the league.
Jones: While the Chargers displayed resilience and discipline in their win, they face tougher challenges ahead. Maintaining consistency and exploring offensive options will be key to their success moving forward.
Was the New England Patriots’ win over the Cincinnati Bengals more about the Patriots’ strength or the Bengals’ challenges?
Jones: The Bengals faced adversity with key absences and early-season rust, impacting their performance. While the Patriots showed promise, it’s essential to consider the context of the game before drawing significant conclusions.
Nguyen: The Patriots capitalized on the Bengals’ vulnerabilities, but Cincinnati’s potential remains intact. Both teams will need time to adjust and find their rhythm as the season progresses.
Pompei: Early-season games can produce unexpected outcomes, and the Bengals’ loss may not be indicative of their long-term prospects. The Patriots’ victory was commendable, but it’s essential to monitor how both teams evolve in the coming weeks.
Assessing the Chicago Bears’ offense following Caleb Williams’ debut
Nguyen: Williams faced challenges in his debut, highlighting the learning curve for rookie quarterbacks in the NFL. The Bears’ defense played a significant role in securing the win, emphasizing the need for offensive improvement moving forward.
Pompei: The Bears’ offense struggled, relying on their defense and special teams for the win. Williams’ performance was underwhelming, indicating the team’s need for offensive refinement to compete effectively.
Jones: Williams’ debut was a learning experience, and the Bears’ offense is a work in progress. With time and adjustments, the team aims to enhance their performance and achieve better results in upcoming games.
Which veteran QB faces more uncertainty after Week 1: Russell Wilson or Kirk Cousins?
Pompei: Wilson and Cousins both face challenges, with Wilson’s position slightly more secure despite Fields’ performance. The Falcons are likely to support Cousins as he navigates his return from injury.
Nguyen: Wilson may feel a sense of unease given Fields’ dynamic abilities, but the Steelers’ victory could sway the decision in favor of experience. Cousins, on the other hand, has the Falcons’ backing as he works through his comeback.
Jones: Neither Wilson nor Cousins should be overly concerned after Week 1. While Fields offers a different dimension, Wilson’s experience gives him an edge. Cousins’ situation with the Falcons reflects a long-term approach, allowing him time to adjust and perform better.
Which fan base needs to pay more attention to college football: Carolina Panthers or New York Giants?
Jones: Both teams have areas of concern, with the Panthers focusing on their defense and the Giants evaluating their quarterback situation. Each franchise must strategically address their weaknesses to achieve success in the season ahead.
Nguyen: The Giants face quarterback challenges, while the Panthers seek defensive improvements. The upcoming games will provide clarity on potential roster adjustments and strategic planning for both teams.
Pompei: The Panthers and Giants have key areas to address for long-term success, with player development and tactical adjustments playing pivotal roles in their progress. Building on existing strengths while addressing weaknesses will be crucial for both franchises.
(Top photo: Nick Cammett / Getty Images)
