The Unheralded Heroes of the MLB Playoff Contenders

Every contending team has star players, but there are also those unsung heroes who play a crucial role in their team’s success during a playoff run. These players often go unnoticed, overshadowed by the big names in the spotlight. It’s time to shine a light on these underrated players and give them the recognition they deserve. I had the opportunity to speak with front-office executives and managers across MLB to identify the most underrated yet indispensable player on each viable postseason contender.

American League

New York Yankees: Austin Wells, C

Austin Wells may have started slow this season, but his improvement over the months has been remarkable. From the bottom of the lineup to a cleanup spot behind the likes of Soto and Judge, Wells has showcased his power and defensive prowess, making him indispensable for the Yankees.

Cleveland Guardians: Set-up relievers Hunter Gaddis, Tim Herrin, and Cade Smith

The Guardians’ set-up relievers have been a force to reckon with this season, boasting impressive stats and playing a significant role in the team’s success on the field.

Houston Astros: Mauricio Dubón, INF/OF

Despite injuries and underperformance in the Astros’ roster, Mauricio Dubón has stepped up to fill the void, showcasing his versatility and contributing both offensively and defensively.

National League

Philadelphia Phillies: Matt Strahm, LHP

Matt Strahm has been a standout performer for the Phillies this season, delivering exceptional results on the mound and proving to be a crucial asset for the team in critical situations.

Los Angeles Dodgers: Tommy Edman, CF

Tommy Edman’s impact on the Dodgers’ lineup has been significant, with his versatility and recent hitting streak making him a key player down the stretch.

Images: Tommy Edman: Katelyn Mulcahy / Getty Images; Albert Suárez: Nick Wass / Associated Press