The Yankee Dilemma: Should Jasson Domínguez Be Called Up?

Excitement is brewing in the world of baseball as the New York Yankees contemplate the possibility of calling up top prospect Jasson Domínguez from Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. With MLB active rosters set to expand to 28 players on Sunday, the Yankees have a decision to make. Will they bring Domínguez to the big leagues, or will they wait?

Jasson Domínguez zooms around the bases on his first triple of 2024 in 11.75 seconds! (110.5 mph EV, no less.)

Only SS Anthony Volpe has posted a faster home-to-third among players still in the @Yankees org this season.@swbrailriders | @NYYPlayerDev pic.twitter.com/LiIE28HmBo

— MLB Pipeline (@MLBPipeline) August 28, 2024

Expert Opinions:

Chris Kirschner: Kirschner believes that calling up Domínguez should be a no-brainer for the Yankees. The young talent could provide a much-needed boost to the team’s left field position, which has struggled this season. Domínguez’s potential impact could be significant as the Yankees push towards October.

Brendan Kuty: While Kuty acknowledges the excitement surrounding Domínguez’s possible call-up, he raises concerns about the practicality of the move. He questions whether the young player can handle the pressure of a playoff race and suggests that his arrival may unsettle the current roster dynamics.

Roster Ramifications:

Kirschner: Kirschner suggests that Domínguez’s call-up could lead to Alex Verdugo losing his starting role in left field. While this move may raise some eyebrows in the clubhouse, Kirschner argues that giving Domínguez a chance could yield better results for the team in the long run.

Kuty: On the other hand, Kuty highlights Verdugo’s defensive capabilities and questions whether the rookie could immediately match his performance. He speculates that a platoon arrangement between Verdugo and a potential external candidate could be a viable solution for the Yankees.

Predictions:

The final decision rests in the hands of the Yankees management. While Domínguez remains a strong candidate for promotion, the team may also explore external options like Tommy Pham or Robbie Grossman to bolster their lineup. Whatever the outcome, all eyes will be on the Yankees as they navigate this critical roster decision.

(Photo of Jasson Domínguez: Cliff Welch / Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)