Aaron Judge is a legendary figure in Major League Baseball, known for breaking records and earning numerous prestigious awards during his time with the New York Yankees. Baseball card collectors have taken notice of this superstar, particularly after his AL Rookie of the Year and AL MVP wins. But with so many options out there, where should you start when it comes to building your collection of Aaron Judge cards? Here are some top picks.

Things to Consider Before Buying

When it comes to the value of sports cards, many factors can influence prices, including card condition, print runs, player performance, market trends, and economic conditions. Typically, card prices are lowest during the offseason. Remember, collecting cards should be enjoyable, regardless of their monetary value. The recommendations below are just starting points for your collection.

One of the best value picks for Aaron Judge cards is his 2013 Bowman Chrome #BDPP19. This card is highly sought after and is a great starting point for any collection.

Best Low-End (~$1-$99) Aaron Judge Cards

For collectors on a budget, the 2017 Topps #287 rookie card is an excellent choice. It’s affordable and in high demand among fans.

2017 Topps #287 Rookie Card

Consider adding this card to your collection as it captures a significant moment in Judge’s career.

More expensive variations and parallels of this card are also available, offering collectors a range of options.

2017 Topps Archives #62 Rookie Card

For fans of classic card designs, this card pays homage to the 1960 Topps set. It combines nostalgia with Judge’s rising star status.

Best Value (~$100-$499) Aaron Judge Cards

For collectors looking to invest a bit more, the 2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects #BDPP19 is an excellent choice. This card represents Judge’s early days with the Yankees and is relatively scarce compared to other cards.

Another top pick in this range is the 2017 Topps Chrome #169 rookie card. It’s a popular choice among collectors and offers various parallel options for those looking for something unique.

Best High-End (~$500+) Aaron Judge Cards

For collectors seeking the best of the best, the 2017 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs #AJ rookie card is a standout choice. Featuring an on-card autograph from Judge, this card is a prized possession for any collection.

Another high-end option is the 2017 Topps Chrome Sapphire Edition #287 rookie card. Known for its rarity and premium quality, this card is a must-have for serious collectors.

Two Other Cool Aaron Judge Cards

For unique additions to your collection, consider the various Kaboom! cards from Panini Absolute and the Topps Now Field of Dreams Game Autograph and Corn Stalk Relic card. These cards offer a special touch to any collection.

Getting the Best Price

When purchasing trading cards, it’s essential to research recent sales to ensure you’re paying a fair price. Utilize tools like eBay’s sold items filter, and consider apps that provide sales data for a more comprehensive view.

Why Trust Us

As a seasoned collector and industry expert, Tyler Holzhammer provides valuable insights and recommendations based on years of experience in the sports card market. Trust his expertise to guide you in building your collection.

How We Selected These Cards

Our recommendations are based on thorough market research and analysis using trusted sources such as eBay’s Terapeak tool and CardLadder. We’ve hand-picked these cards based on their value, popularity, and grading population to help collectors make informed decisions.

Disclaimer: The Athletic maintains editorial independence in all our content. When you make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.

Further Reading

(Top photo by Sam Hodde/Getty Images; all card images: eBay)